CMMS vs. Asset Management: A Guide to Bridging the Gap
Answered September 04 2020
What Is Operational Excellence?
Step one is to understand what operational excellence means:
- All efforts throughout the organization are in alignment.
- The goals of the organization have been effectively conveyed.
- All assets, resources, and efforts are focused on attaining the organization’s goals.
- The corporate culture is singularly committed to the mission/vision statement.
- The culture includes effective leadership, stewardship, and followership.
- The organization seeks to instill a sense of pride and ownership in everyone.
- The organization performs regular benchmarking to align product with marketplace.
- The focus is continuous improvement in a calculated matter to be competitively positioned.
- The organization seeks profitability and promotes social/environmental responsibility.
Understand Your Current State
The sales and marketing teams think big. They realize that software when implemented correctly can achieve great results. Therefore the sales brochure might make these promises:
- Decrease in yearly maintenance costs after installing CMMS software
- Increase in availability by 1-6%
- Reduction in safety risks by 10-30%
- Reduce reactive maintenance by 10-50%
But if you only plan to create work order tickets and report actuals, then the above goals may be too optimistic.
Did CMMS implementation deliver operational excellence? Probably not. Did capturing work order costs deliver better reliability/availability? Probably not. Did the workforce achieve improved productivity and job safety? Were you able to automate weekly scheduling or extract a bad actor list? Probably not. I suspect many organizations invested heavily in the technology but are still in a reactive mode. So, what is missing?
Without a strong background in asset management and advanced processes, there is a good chance that you will only end up with an expensive work order ticket system. More work will come in than you can complete, and you will lose control of the backlog. You may be able to track completed work by month but not be able to identify bad actors.
CMMS Utilization Hurdles
Oftentimes there are man-made issues associated with CMMS utilization. The top ten are:
- Strategic roles missing – No core team, asset manager, reliability team, or business analyst.
- Limited knowledge in asset management – A lack of industry best practices, they don’t know what they don’t know.
- Poor vision – No strategic asset management plan, CMMS utilization plan, long-range plan, or benchmarking.
- Lack of analytical reporting – Stakeholders assumed the CMMS would have what they needed.
- Poor data quality (foundational and transactional) – No data quality plan or formal error checking, unclear update roles/procedures, setup of the preventive maintenance library was not defendable, and difficulty finding parts in the warehouse due to non-standard descriptions.
- Lack of product training and asset management concepts.
- High click count – Too hard to use, no mobile solution.
- Organization nonalignment – CMMS project team never received input from senior management as to what they thought was essential (i.e., data and reports), or the project team didn’t involve the reliability engineers during implementation.
- CMMS was never configured to support failure mode capture – The language of reliability-centered maintenance.
- Overall culture – Goals not aligned, workers have general mistrust of the management’s purpose for the CMMS (i.e., performing people tracking as opposed to asset management). Also, workers seeing the software as a tool to measure their performance and feeling threatened.
Once the issues are known, then combine into one document and prioritize. It’s easy to become defeated and wonder how one person can make a difference. But this is how all projects really get started. My advice is to take a stand by creating a data quality plan and presenting this to leadership, to describe a path forward. The goal is to identify the shortest path to value.
Chicken and the Egg: Which Comes First?
Naturally, this is a complex problem with many interactions. And how do you know what the endgame for asset management should look like until you see what the ideal design should look like? And how do you know if you are underutilizing the CMMS? The answer is to perform aggressive benchmarking. The first action is to talk with your peers and listen carefully. But also pursue your own research, such as reading books, magazines, internet articles, and attending conferences. However, the venues cannot just be technology conferences. Instead the events should be heavy on reliability and asset management concepts.
Here’s a Little-Known Fact
There are essentially two worlds within asset management, and they are the CMMS practitioners and the maintenance/reliability professionals. Unfortunately, they don’t normally mingle, either at the office or by attending the same conferences. My suggestion is to figure out a way to start communicating with each other and develop a common language. If the reliability engineer would speak with the CMMS team, the reliability engineer might find a way to capture data that adds value, or to design a failure analytic which shows bad actors. And together, when they encounter a new idea, they would compare it to the corporate or department objectives and see if it adds value (not every idea does).
Convert Ideas into an Action Plan
One idea might be to set up the CMMS to support reliability engineering. And once you realize that the CMMS can actually be used to make data-based decisions, then you are off to the races. As an example, chronic failure analysis would be a worthy endeavor. The key is to design analytical reports which leverage failure data to manage by exception. This is an advanced process which requires a failure analytic, accurate failure data on the work order, clear update roles, and a reliability action team to perform the analysis.
But Will the Moment of Realization Happen?
This is a huge unknown. Every site is different and benchmarking may be totally foreign as a process, i.e., no one may be allowed to attend conferences. Sometimes people are working in silos with their head down and no desire to improve. But if a spark can be generated, then an action plan can be created. Some organizations go so far as to create a long-range plan because they have so many initiatives.
There Are Several Key Roles
I sometimes call these strategic roles. In a perfect world, there might be reliability leaders everywhere. But this is not always the case. A better bet would be to set up the following positions. At the executive level, you want someone who has a general understanding of asset management to purpose, benefit, and improve return on asset (ROA). Beyond that, it helps to have an asset manager with budget authority, so that improvement projects can be initiated.
Quite often, the organization assigns all things asset-management-related to the IT department since they originally purchased the CMMS. But being that advanced processes require software/data, process/procedure, and roles/responsibilities, these improvement initiatives involve much more than software. The asset manager would be the primary owner of the strategic asset management plan, long-range plan, and act as a key player to establishing a reliability culture.
If you don’t have a core team, this is where I would place immediate focus. Managing the CMMS is too much for one person (i.e., CMMS administrator). Plus, it’s always better to have cross-department representation. This group would create a utilization plan for CMMS operation and a data quality plan. In addition, they would write CMMS procedures and conduct training. The core team also tracks all issues, software, or process-related tasks.
A business analyst should interview all stakeholders and document system requirements, even after going live. The business analyst is the first person to know if there is a lack of buy-in, i.e., a culture problem. This role would conduct periodic surveys, process/data audits, and training. The analyst would also create a functional specification in the case of a new report and request from the user community.
This role separates the best from the rest. If an organization complains continually about lack of accuracy in the CMMS, this is the role that promotes data accuracy. The gatekeeper would review all incoming work and verify validity and completeness. They would assign primary support craft if missing and enter a rough estimate. This action by itself ensures that the entire backlog will have some kind of craft estimate, which helps with backlog sizing and growth trending. It also enables automatic resource leveling based on backlog ranking to help planners determine what should be planned first.
The gatekeeper would also create user grading sheets to monitor work order accuracy. An incomplete or sloppy entry slows down the entire process, makes the planner job harder, and could impact the response time. During work order completion, the gatekeeper could also be involved with reviewing failure data for completeness.
Reliability Action Team
This is a group of stakeholders who take action to promote asset integrity, workforce productivity, and job safety. They also would rely heavily on failure data within the CMMS, using a failure analytic to drill down on failure modes. In a monthly meeting, they might do the following:
- Review bad actors and drill down on failure modes.
- Analyze reactive maintenance, unplanned downtime, and high-cost work.
- Initiate root cause analysis when required.
- Assess defect elimination status.
- Evaluate degrading asset condition.
- Examine significant work order feedback.
Senior Management Responsibilities
When things don’t go right, it’s easy to say leadership is always the problem. But what can we do as middle-level managers, supervisors, and the working level to assist them? Here are some ideas:
- Provide accurate and timely CMMS updates (e.g., work order actuals, status, and failure coding)
- Provide valuable work order feedback (e.g., maintainability, design flaws, preventive maintenance frequency, job step clarity, hazard identification, asset condition, ergonomics, and energy inefficiency)
- Ensure day-to-day communication with your boss
- Submit ideas to CMMS (asset management) issues tracking (e.g., more training is needed, missing reports)
- Support Kaizen sessions for operations and maintenance staff, operator-driven reliability training, and operators providing shift turnover using electronic log notes
- Have maintenance staff conduct toolbox talks and share job hazards with co-workers
- Defect elimination teams identify and fix problems—small and large
- Post outage critique sessions
- Pursue personal knowledge related to asset management concepts through individual research
- Help others communicate better, i.e., ask the reliability engineer if they could have any report from the CMMS to help them make better decisions, what would it be and what would it look like?
As for CMMS utilization and asset management best practices, sometimes it takes a while before senior management (and other stakeholders) fully understand what the system can do and what they want out of the system. Therein someone might request a workshop to discuss analytical reports (e.g., failure analytic), data accuracy, and the inputs necessary to support these outputs.
Where Can I Receive Training in Asset Management Best Practices?
The following curriculum offers training in advanced processes for asset management. Course details can be provided by sending a request to [email protected]
An overview of this content is shown below.
There are no world-class maintenance organizations, but there can be world-class asset management teams.
Life is short; indecisiveness can delay most any project. Sometimes it’s the people who know best who fail to take a stand. But the fact is, every day you wait on capturing validated failure data, is data that you’ll never recover. And because this data was not captured, analytical reports cannot be run to identify bad actors. For some, they might be overwhelmed with so many ideas to consider and not know where to start. A one-day assessment would help decision-makers pull together all initiatives into a prioritized list. And by working on this prioritized list, you will be managing risk and following the shortest path to value.
Latest Maintenance Articles
- What Are Ideal Preventive Maintenance Schedules for Manufacturing Equipment?Root Cause Analysis Techniques and FundamentalsHow to Use eBay to Save Money and Time on ProcurementThe Ultimate Guide to Programmable Logic Controllers (PLCs)How to Respond to an FDA Warning LetterWhat Is Maintenance Process Mapping?
Fleet Management and GPS
Oil & Gas
Asset Management Questions & Answers
Root Cause Analysis Techniques and Fundamentals
Root cause analysis (RCA) is key to a successful maintenance program. But to conduct one effectively, it’s critical to understand the components required.
What Is Maintenance Process Mapping?
Without effective maintenance process mapping, an organization will never achieve stable maintenance processes. Learn what you need to know here.
8 Steps to Implementing SOPs in Your Maintenance Team
Implementing standard operating procedures (SOPs) may be a challenge. In this article, we’ll discuss various aspects of how to tackle this challenge.
What Is a Standard Operating Procedure (SOP)?
A standard operating procedure, or SOP, is a document that lays out the steps to do something in a clear and concise way.
SCADA Systems Explained | Onupkeep.com
SCADA is a computer control system used to monitor and control plant processes. It uses data communications and more to monitor systems.
What are different types of food and beverage processing equipment?
We've compiled every type of food and beverage processing equipment out there in a list with everything you need to know.
What Is Straight Line Depreciation, and Why Does It Matter?
Straight Line Depreciation is an accounting method, and accounting is not the first thing you might associate with maintenance.
7 Metrics You Should Be Tracking for Maintenance Inventory
To get the very most out of your MRO (maintenance, reliability, and operations) inventory, you need to track data that reflects costs, turnover, etc.
What is Asset Management & ISO 55000?
An asset is any item that has potential or actual value to the company. Asset management is an approach to achieve the most asset value.
What’s a function and what’s functional failure?
A function describes the intention of a piece of equipment, while functional failures detail conditions that would prevent equipment from peak operation.
What is asset management? What are the top asset management certifications?
Asset management is generally defined as a system of activities that an organization performs to gain value from assets, including design and maintenance.
What are maintenance tasks to perform on indoor cycling bikes?
Maintenance tasks for indoor cycling bikes include daily, weekly and monthly cleaning, inspection, and adjustments to ensure strong durability.
What are some types of assistive devices and how are they used?
Assistive devices help individuals with disabilities live a more independent life by using technology and increasing everyday accessibility.
What is a Purchase Order and What to Include?
Purchase orders (POs) are created to start a purchasing relationship with an outside vendor. POs include quantity, delivery schedule, and payment terms.
What is maintenance management?
Maintenance management is the process of maintaining a company’s resources. It ensures efficient production and effective use of resources.
What are the most common ISO standards for manufacturing facilities to follow?
The most common ISO standards to follow for manufacturing facilities are ISO 55000, 55001, and 55002. All require an asset management system.
What is a bathtub curve?
A bathtub curve is a visual of a product's failure rate over time that maps out three periods that an asset experiences within its lifetime.
6 Interesting Facts About Equipment Failure
When it comes to equipment failure, there are a few interesting trends that we see. We can see some of the challenges effective reliability planning.
What are the phases of a turnaround maintenance procedure?
In maintenance, a turnaround is an event where one or more assets are temporarily removed from service so that maintenance tasks can be performed.
How much should I budget for maintenance for my equipment?
You should budget approximately 2% to 5% of your total RAV. This metric, known as %RAV, is calculated as a proportion of your facility's value and spending.
What is a fixed asset?
A fixed asset is one of two major categories of physical property for a company and includes those items that remain in one location during business operation.
What are the most common root cause analysis (RCA) mistakes and how do I avoid them?
Some of the most common root cause analysis mistakes involve poor definitions, focusing on the wrong thing, or ignoring root causes entirely.
How do I conduct a thorough root cause analysis?
For root cause analysis to be effective, you need to dig deep, have the right resources, and ask “Why?” until you get to a root cause.
How to Measure Inventory Performance with Inventory Management Metrics
To measure performance in inventory management, one of the most common metrics to use is “number of inventory turns" and target a value greater than 1.0.
What is the importance of collecting equipment failure data?
The collection of equipment failure data over time determines the reliability of your facility and enables proper asset management and life-cycle analysis.
Which root cause analysis (RCA) method should I use?
Of the numerous RCA methods used, the one you choose depends on the depth and nature of the problem, as well as the number of contributing causes.
When should I repair or replace an asset?
In order to decide if it is time to repair or replace an asset, you must compare the current value of the asset with the cost of repair.
What is Equipment Depreciation? Why it Matters + How to Calculate
Equipment depreciation is a measure of how much a piece of equipment drops in value each year. Using depreciation, you can make wiser maintenance decisions.
What is an asset life cycle?
An asset life cycle refers to the stages involved in the management of an asset. The life cycle of an asset starts with the planning stages.
What is the difference between availability and reliability?
Availability measures equipment's ability to operate, while reliability measures the ability of equipment to perform without failure.
What’s idle time and how does it differ from downtime?
Idle time is the time in which an asset is either waiting to run or isn’t scheduled to run and downtime is when the asset is incapable of running.
What is the difference between criticality and risk analysis with regards to maintenance and reliability?
Criticality is a measure of how important an asset is to your process. The more critical the asset, the more of an impact it will have if fails.
What is the difference between total effective equipment performance (TEEP) and overall equipment effectiveness (OEE)?
Overall equipment effectiveness (OEE), the most common metricperformance of a plant, is expressed as a percentage of the total production time.
What are leading and lagging metrics in maintenance?
Indicators are classified according to whether they predict future performance or describe past performance –- referred to as leading or lagging indicators.
What are ways to improve my equipment uptime?
There are numerous ways to improve your equipment uptime, each of which has to do with streamlining your maintenance processes.
What are the best metrics and KPIs for manufacturing companies?
Downtime and uptime are the heartbeats of a manufacturer - when the facility has too much downtime, the health of the organization suffers.
What’s the difference between downtime and breakdown time?
Breakdown time is downtime that results from the equipment breaking down. Equipment downtime is any time a piece of equipment is offline.
What are the maintenance costs associated with one unit of production?
The maintenance unit cost is a snapshot of the total maintenance cost required to manufacture a standard unit of production during a set period of time.
How would I implement a total productive maintenance program?
When implementing total productive maintenance (TPM), I think it’s best to gradually phase it in. It will enable an organization-wide adjustment over time.
What is the best way to use failure codes for root cause analysis?
Use failure codes systematically: start with analyzing the reasons for failures, code this information in a consistent way, and make it accessible.
What are the five pillars of maintenance and reliability?
The SMRP identified five pillars of maintenance and reliability to help facility managers create a framework for their businesses.
How much should I be spending on maintenance for industrial equipment and assets?
One such goal is to strive for spending 3 percent or less of your replacement asset value (RAV) annually on maintenance costs. Here are the details.
Should I use barcodes or RFID tags to track my equipment and assets?
Both bar codes and RFID tags can help you track your assets and equipment; and each has its own unique advantages and disadvantages.
Useful life of an Asset: Definition & Examples
IRS Publication 946, Appendix B, lists useful life estimates by industry and application. These estimates can be used as a baseline.
What do I do with old industrial equipment?
Either you replace old equipment, or you keep it around. The route you choose depends on your facility’s current demands.
What is the difference between PLC and SCADA?
The primary difference between a PLC (or Programmable Logic Controller) and SCADA is the fact that a PLC is hardware and SCADA is generally software
What are the dangers of using the mean time between failure (MTBF) metric?
When MTBF is presented you cannot instantly ascertain whether the metric is being influenced more by the uptime duration or by the number of breakdowns.
Is maintenance cost to asset value ratio a good maintenance metric?
The short answer to the question is generally “no”. However, asking the question sets into motion the bigger issue of how to evaluate any metric in facilities management.
What does a good electric motor testing program look like?
Implementing a good electric motor testing (EMT) program can be a massive positive investment in the reliability of a facility's equipment.
Am I spending too much (or too little) on maintenance activities?
A common metric is taking the total maintenance cost (MC) as a percentage of the estimated plant replacement value (PRV).
When do I need to hire a reliability engineer? How does reliability affect safety?
If you want to take proactive steps towards maintenance and you have enough data to analyze, you can benefit from hiring a reliability engineer.
How do you implement an asset life cycle management program?
Implementing a stellar asset life cycle management program requires alignment with your business strategy, data-driven decisions, and the right culture.
What are the 8 kinds of waste in Lean Six Sigma?
All continuous improvement programs and computerized maintenance systems strive for the common goal of reducing this waste as much as possible.
How can you achieve world class manufacturing reliability?
World-class manufacturing facilities successfully stay ahead of breakdowns, achieve higher asset utilization, reduce maintenance costs, and increase safety.
How can you make rotating equipment operate better, for longer?
To answer that, we should first understand exactly what causes rotating equipment to fail. The majority of failures come down to unbalance and misalignment.
What mistakes do maintenance teams make when lubricating bearings?
Overall, the main mistakes I’ve seen with lubricating bearings have to do with either too much lubrication or too little.
What makes a reliability engineer great?
Finding causes of problems can be tricky, and convincing maintenance technicians to accept new practices can be even trickier. Here are some ideas to help:
What are common mistakes reliability engineers make?
Reliability engineering is a complex process with lots of room for potential errors, lost time, and wasted money. Stay forward thinking and proactive.
What are common misconceptions about plant maintenance?
More people on maintenance staff doesn't necessarily reduce problems. In fact, it creates another kind of problem in terms of ineffective resource use
What are the benefits of infrared imaging?
Infrared analysis is actually super useful for checking temperatures, especially when you're comparing the temperature of an asset to another asset.
What mistakes are common with reliability-centered maintenance?
While RCM seems simple on its face, there are a huge number of moving parts within any solid reliability-centered maintenance plan that could go wrong.
When should I perform preventive maintenance on equipment?
Begin by checking the OEM manual. This will typically provide you with preventive maintenance guidelines. dffdadfdsfasdfasdfasdf
How do you track asset depreciation?
In order to track asset depreciation, you'll use its annual depreciation. The formula is (Initial Cost - Salvage Value) ÷ Useful Life = Annual Depreciation.
How do you determine which machines should receive preventive maintenance?
Selecting machines for preventive maintenance is a matter of finding which ones would benefit most from PM while keeping maintenance costs down.
Where should you store equipment manuals and warranties?
A CMMS is a great way to organize user manuals and warranties by asset. Upload them and they’re ready to view by anyone with access.